With the majority of the league's participants over the years having been dudes, the inevitable pissing contest would always arise – who, amongst the hundreds of guys that have laced up their shoes, was at the top. Well, we've decided to showcase the best of the best in this list, determining the rankings by selecting each bowler’s best season-ending average.*Here are the Top 25 Male Bowlers of All Time:
| Top 25 Male Bowlers of All Time | ||||
| Rank | Bowler | Average | Total Pins | Season |
| 1. | Brian Coe | 219 | 10545 | Fall 2014 |
| 2. | Don Glasscock | 219 | 9202 | Fall 2007 |
| 3. | Kody Karnes | 214 | 10290 | Spring 2014 |
| 4. | Carl Goetz | 212 | 10182 | Spring 2015 |
| 5. | Ken M. Wilson | 210 | 10108 | Spring 2013 |
| 6. | Matthew Taylor | 206 | 7416 | Spring 2021 |
| 7. | David Codding | 204 | 7377 | Fall 2009 |
| 8. | Ian Goetz | 203 | 9758 | Spring 2015 |
| 9. | Cory Chorpenning | 203 | 8530 | Fall 2008 |
| 10. | Ryan Doll | 201 | 9047 | Fall 2014 |
| 11. | Aaron Barber | 200 | 9609 | Spring 2018 |
| 12. | Bill Krejci | 199 | 7180 | Spring 2013 |
| 13. | Aubrey Moren | 198 | 8328 | Spring 2014 |
| 14. | Michael Gordon | 198 | 6534 | Spring 2021 |
| 15. | John Boren | 196 | 9415 | Spring 2016 |
| 16. | Duncan Ferber | 195 | 8220 | Fall 2007 |
| 17. | Landon Cline | 194 | 8755 | Fall 2016 |
| 18. | Michael Mead | 193 | 9280 | Fall 2017 |
| 19. | Seth Gunderson | 193 | 8142 | Spring 2015 |
| 20. | Dennis Walling | 193 | 4653 | Fall 2020 |
| 21. | Pat Searcy | 191 | 8025 | Fall 2004 |
| 22. | Kendall Kukowski | 188 | 8487 | Fall 2008 |
| 23. | Jason Carpio | 188 | 6212 | Fall 2011 |
| 24. | Brian Eye | 187 | 9006 | Fall 2007 |
| 25. | Russell Bingham | 186 | 6705 | Spring 2018 |
